Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler — The Decision in 2026
The economics of replacing a UK gas boiler with an air-source heat pump (ASHP) depend on three numbers: the install cost gap (after grants), the electricity-to-gas price ratio, and the SCOP (seasonal efficiency) you'll actually get. Get all three right and a heat pump matches or beats gas on lifetime cost. Get them wrong and you'll pay more.
Install Costs (UK May 2026, fully fitted)
- New combi gas boiler: £2,500–£4,000
- System gas boiler with cylinder: £3,500–£5,500
- Air-source heat pump (8–12 kW): £10,000–£16,000 (before grant)
- Ground-source heat pump: £18,000–£35,000 (before grant)
- Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS) grant: £7,500 toward ASHP/GSHP
So a typical UK install gap is £6K–£8K extra for a heat pump after the grant.
Running Cost Maths
To produce 12,000 kWh of heat in a UK home with average kit:
- 92% efficient gas boiler: 12,000 ÷ 0.92 = 13,043 kWh of gas × 6p = £783/year
- SCOP 3.0 heat pump: 12,000 ÷ 3.0 = 4,000 kWh of electricity × 28p = £1,120/year on standard tariff
- Same heat pump on Octopus Cosy off-peak (~13p/kWh): ~£520/year — beats gas decisively
The Tariff Lever
Heat-pump tariffs are the killer feature. Octopus Cosy charges ~13p/kWh during three off-peak windows when the heat pump can do most of its work charging a buffer tank or running flow temps higher. OVO Heat Pump Plus caps electricity at gas-equivalent prices for verified heat-pump users. With these tariffs, heat pump running costs match or undercut gas.
Will a Heat Pump Work in My House?
- Insulation: EPC C or better is best; D is workable; E or worse — fix insulation first
- Radiators: 30–50% of homes need at least some larger rads (heat pumps run cooler flow temperatures)
- Outdoor space: ~1 m × 1 m ground space + 1 m clearance for ASHP outdoor unit
- Hot water: a hot-water cylinder is required (combi boilers without one need replacement plumbing)
- Power supply: single-phase usually fine; check with installer
Carbon Savings
A typical heat pump cuts heating-related CO₂ by ~70%. UK gas emits 0.182 kg CO₂/kWh; UK grid electricity is now ~0.21 kg CO₂/kWh and falling. So 12,000 kWh of heat from gas → 2.4 tonnes CO₂; from a SCOP 3.0 ASHP → 0.84 tonnes — a ~1.6 tonne annual saving. Over 15 years that's ~24 tonnes — equivalent to taking a car off the road for 6 years.
What This Calculator Doesn't Include
- Radiator/cylinder upgrade costs (often £500–£3,000 for older homes)
- Heat-pump-specific electricity tariffs (Octopus Cosy, OVO Heat Pump Plus)
- Solar PV synergy (free daytime electricity boosts heat pump economics massively)
- Future gas price rises (Ofgem cap rose ~50% over 2021–2024)
- Property value uplift / EPC rating improvement
Related Calculators
- Solar Panel Payback Calculator — Cost, generation, savings, SEG income, payback and 25-year ROI for residential PV.
- EV Charging Cost Calculator — Cost per charge, per mile and annual electric running cost vs petrol. Home, public, rapid mix.
- Carbon Footprint Calculator — Estimate your annual CO₂ emissions from transport, home energy, diet and lifestyle. Compare to global averages.